Results 1 to 4 of 4

Thread: CW Post fires dorm advisors over 'hostage' movie

  1. #1
    Senior Member RDU-JFK's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2005
    Location
    Los Angeles, CA
    Posts
    1,185

    CW Post fires dorm advisors over 'hostage' movie

    CW Post fires dorm advisors over 'hostage' movie
    BY HERBERT LOWE, OLIVIA WINSLOW AND JENNIFER KELLEHER
    Newsday Staff Writers

    February 7, 2007, 1:24 PM EST

    A two-minute video that administrators consider insensitive to Muslims has cost five resident assistants and a residence hall advisor their jobs at the C.W. Post campus of Long Island University, according to the editor of the campus newspaper.

    The short film depicts a scene similar to one where Americans being held hostage by Al-Qaeda terrorists are forced to shoot videos pleading for their life, according to an account scheduled to be published on Wednesday in the Pioneer newspaper.




    Instead of a human victim, a white rubber duck named Pete is being held "hostage." The film is called "A Duck Napping," and the rubber duck is the mascot for a campus residence hall, Brookville Hall, the Pioneer reported.

    According to the Pioneer, in the video the five resident assistants are disguised in ski masks and speaking broken English and using stereotypical "Middle Eastern" accents. The description of the video, which was posted on YouTube and Google Video and later taken down, describes the chatter as farcical demands for the duck's safe release.

    Reaction to the C.W. Post administration's handling of the matter has caused a "tremendous uproar" on the Brookville campus, said Danny Schrafel, the Pioneer editor-in-chief.

    "I've been working on the paper a little over three-and-a-half years now and this is probably the biggest scandal I've seen on campus that entire time," Schrafel said.

    He described the campus as split into two camps: People who believe the resident assistants were fired unjustly and people who were offended by the video.

    In a statement provided to Newsday Wednesday, C.W. Post Provost Joseph Shenker defended the administration's response.

    "At C.W. Post, we take seriously our obligation to create a campus environment that is free of prejudice and intolerance," Shenker said. "We do not condone any behaviors that demean the dignity of individuals or groups of people. We don't find anything about terrorism and hostage-taking to be humorous. We insist on a campus where respect for others is demonstrated at all times."

    Shenker added: "Five student employees were engaged in a serious incident that violated their employment contract with the university. These students are now participating in our student conduct judicial process."

    The Pioneer reported that the resident assistants were allowed to keep their free meal plan and room and board for the rest of the semester, provided they work 10 hours a week in a student affairs office.

    The five resident assistants -- all seniors -- are Bert Estrada, a film major; Dustin Frye, a biology and psychology major; Robert Bennett, a history major; Jordan Marmara, a biology education major and Billy McDermott, a criminal justice major, the Pioneer reported. They worked in the Brookville Lodge A/B Complex and were dismissed on Feb. 2.

    Kristin Kielczewski, the residence hall director, was forced to resign on Feb. 1, the newspaper reported.

    Matthew Bartlett, a 19-year old freshman from Clifton N.J., who lives in one of the dorms where one of the dismissed student employees works, called McDermott a "a great guy."

    "I'm upset they fired him," Bartlett said. "I'm pretty appalled by what they did because I don't think it's fair. It's our right as students to express ourselves. We're in college."

    Bartlett said he had not seen the film, but he defended it even, he said, if its makers had intended to offend others: "It's film. It's art. It is intended to offend people sometimes."

    At the campus' Brookville Hall, where some of the fired resident assistants work, fliers were posted: "Support your RAs. Freedom of Speech encompasses all of America. ... Even Long Island University."
    Unbelievable. This reminds me of the Drew Carey episode where Drew's alleged to be committing sexual harassment by blowing up a cartoon of a caterpillar and a frenchfry.
    "I can't wait until tomorrow, cause I get better looking everyday"
    --Joe Namath

  2. #2
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Apr 2005
    Posts
    8,285
    "At C.W. Post, we take seriously our obligation to create a campus environment that is free of prejudice and intolerance," Shenker said. "We do not condone any behaviors that demean the dignity of individuals or groups of people. We don't find anything about terrorism and hostage-taking to be humorous. We insist on a campus where respect for others is demonstrated at all times."
    I guess they don't condone free speech and expression of art?

  3. #3
    Senior Member hiss srq's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2005
    Location
    Around here and near there.
    Posts
    5,565
    so much for living in the US than
    Southwest Airlines-"Once it pop's it's time to stop" Southwest Airlines-"Our Shamu's are almost real" Southwest Airlines -"We blow our top real easy" Southwest Airlines- "You can't top us..... really"

  4. #4
    Senior Member moose135's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2005
    Location
    Long Island, NY
    Posts
    8,067
    Not to point at you Tommy, but the "free speech" argument is meaningless. CW Post is part of Long Island University, which is a private university. That means they get to make the rules about conduct of their employees, including what they can say or do, while employed by the university. The right of "Freedom of Speech" that everyone throws around means that the government can't make laws restricting what a person says (well, with some exceptions). It has no bearing on how a private organization acts. If I made offensive remarks in public, Newsday could fire me, and I wouldn't have the First Amendment to fall back on (ironic, isn't it. )

    In this case, these people apparently did something which offended a significant portion of the university's population, and management acted within their rights to discipline school employees.

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •