PDA

View Full Version : need advice on an edit



threeholerglory
2009-07-24, 01:07 AM
I recently did a re-edit on this photo. I mainly only corrected the keystoning effect in the bridge towers since they appeared to be falling over due to the wide angle lens. Though I am much happier with this edit, I still feel like it is lacking....can anyone offer some advice? Thanks!

http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2639/3751539854_4a351cabc1_o.jpg

Matt Molnar
2009-07-24, 01:23 AM
Looks great to me, not sure what else you can do with it.

Derf
2009-07-24, 11:46 AM
I think it lacks a little punch, here you can see the slight color shift gives the image a lot more punch
http://derf.smugmug.com/photos/600457690_AGwVi-O.jpg

I do like the original, very nice :borat:

threeholerglory
2009-07-24, 12:13 PM
i like that a lot too, Fred. Though I think whatever color shift you used produced a couple artifacts. I like it. I feel like the more I look at it, the more I feel like the verticals on the bridge still aren't quite right....

lijk604
2009-07-24, 12:41 PM
The verticles on the bridge seem to be leaning outward a bit still. Try using the lens distortion filter in Photoshop to bring them in just a scoch. The only other thing that "I" see, is that because it was taken so late at night, the B&W actually hurst the image, as there is no depth to it. A little light color in the sky should help. But that's just my 2 cents.

emshighway
2009-07-24, 01:01 PM
The left tower does have a lean. The reflection from the lights under the left tower onto the water also draws my attention too much.

Matt Molnar
2009-07-24, 01:20 PM
Fixed:

http://www.nycaviation.com/hosting/wtc-bb-fake.jpg

threeholerglory
2009-07-24, 04:27 PM
amen to that......i wish i could have gotten that shot with the towers!

Matt Molnar
2009-07-24, 05:39 PM
Me too. I only found that spot after I started working in that neighborhood, a few months after 9/11. Got some nice shots of the towers of light from there, though.

emshighway
2009-07-24, 09:37 PM
Fixed:

http://www.nycaviation.com/hosting/wtc-bb-fake.jpg

If only it was that easy.

moose135
2009-07-24, 09:53 PM
I adjusted the bridge towers so they look vertical (I may have gone a little too far on the left side...) and I darkened the distracting bright reflection under the left side of the bridge.

http://moose135.smugmug.com/photos/600870708_74KdN-L-1.jpg

threeholerglory
2009-07-25, 01:45 AM
thanks moose, that looks a lot more like where it should be. What method did you use? My Scott Kelby books recommend free transforming the image. Originally, the towers leaned to the right...I guess I went a tad too far with it.

moose135
2009-07-25, 01:56 AM
I used the Rectangular Marquee to select the entire image, then used Edit>Transform>Skew. That lets you select an individual corner and drag it left or right (or up and down) to adjust the photo - I adjusted both the top left and top right individually to correct each side. I had a set of grid lines turned on to help judge the verticals. I was left with a trapezoid shaped photo, which I cropped to a 3x2 format.

emshighway
2009-07-25, 03:06 PM
I adjusted the bridge towers so they look vertical (I may have gone a little too far on the left side...) and I darkened the distracting bright reflection under the left side of the bridge.

http://moose135.smugmug.com/photos/600870708_74KdN-L-1.jpg

Moose, looks awesome to me.

threeholerglory
2009-07-25, 08:30 PM
i concur....thanks a lot for the help....it's always great to have a few extra sets of eyes to have a look. I like your composition much better too, thanks moose!