Editorials

January 25, 2019

What Did and Didn’t Happen at LaGuardia Today?

So let’s talk about what happened (and didn’t happen) at LaGuardia and a few other airports today.

There was a shortage of air traffic controllers at both Washington Center (ZDC) and Jacksonville Center (ZJX) which disrupted air travel up and down the east coast. How short they were we just don’t know. The FAA said it was a “slight increase” in the number of absences, but no actual numbers were revealed. The shortage caused capacity for those centers to decrease as sectors were combined. At some point, the number of flights wishing to transit those airspaces exceeded the available capacity.

To manage the overcapacity problem, the FAA Command Center in Virginia instituted a ground stop (flights are halted until the stop is lifted) and ground delay program (flights are delayed for an amount of time determined by the FAA) for LGA. Why LGA you ask? It’s a highly congested airport which is always going to make it a candidate to show early signs of a problem. Windy conditions at LGA didn’t help things either. LaGuardia wasn’t the only airport to see delays attributed to staffing however. In the northeast, PHL and EWR were affected. In the south, TPA was affected early, while delays hit ATL and MIA later in the morning. These are delays which the FAA attributed to “staffing” or “volume” only.

LaGuardia never “shut down” as many outlets reported. This was a misinterpretation of what the term “ground stop” meant. While at one point just before the stop was lifted only 4 flights were in the air destined for LGA, flights never stopped arriving or departing. The stop served its purpose by preventing gridlock in the ground at LGA. Remember that the lack of capacity would affect flights both coming and going from LGA as long as they flew through ZDC’s airspace.

What caused the staffing issues? Yesterday, the US Office of Personnel Management (OPM) issued guidance allowing federal employees that were deemed essential during the shutdown to take leave. Previous guidance had been that they were not allowed to take leave. This new guidance had the effect of opening a pressure release valve. We’ve seen reports over the past few weeks of illness spreading around ATC facilities as controllers were forced to come in sick. Today, with the new guidance in place, they were finally able to stay home and take a sick day. And I’m sure that at least a couple opted to take leave to work at their paying side hustle.

One thing we are certain of is that this was not an organized sickout or any other type of labor action. The 1981 PATCO strike is still very much in the rear view mirror for NATCA, and we’ve heard from multiple people that union leadership has been extrordinarily proactive in discouraging any type of organized job action within the air traffic controller ranks. A wildcat strike or organized sickout would have likely been devastating to both the union and the national airspace system.

The good news is that as of a little while ago, the shutdown is over. At least for the next 3 weeks. And we’ve seen communications from NATCA that controllers should see their base pay minus a fixed withholding in 2 installments late next week. Overtime, other adjustments, and proper withholding amounts will be calculated afterwards.



About the Author

Ben Granucci
Ben Granucci, Senior Editor, is an aviation enthusiast and plane spotter based in New York City. Growing up in Connecticut, he has had his eyes toward the sky for as long as he can remember. He can be reached at [email protected]. Follow him on Twitter.




 
 

 

How Existing Funding Could Keep The FAA Open In A Future Shutdown

The government shutdown drags on, and is now in its third week. Tom Rainey Jr. explores how Congress could insulate the FAA's operations from a future shutdown, primarily using existing funding.
by Tom Rainey
0

 
 

OPINION: Privatization Is Not The Answer For Our ATC System

Columnist Dave Williams takes a look at President Trump's proposal to privatize the nation's air traffic control system, and finds that there are more cons than there are pros.
by David J. Williams
0

 

 

OPINION: The Issues Behind Air Traffic Control Reform

Air Traffic Control privatization is being considered by Congress. Let's take a close look at the process, the prospects, and some of the top issues.
by Tom Rainey
0

 
 

ATC Reform: The President’s Push for the Privatization of Air Traffic Control

On Monday, President Trump threw his support behind a renewed plan to privatize air traffic control services in the United States.
by Stephanie Gehman
2

 
 

OPINION: The Risks of Reducing The FAA’s Control Of Our Aviation Infrastructure

As a new presidential administration prepares to take over, questions loom regarding the future of how the FAA will control the nation's aviation infrastructure.
by David J. Williams
0